James Madison warned in Federalist No. 10 that factions would corrupt the legislative process and undermine the public good. Here we are, proving him right.
Two dominant players in today's faction game, lobbying groups and think tanks, have hijacked our voices and now control what becomes law.
Think Tanks and Lobbying Groups
Lobbying groups walk into the statehouse with wish lists disguised as legislation. They draft the laws and present them as ready-made solutions. Legislators grab these pre-packaged bills and parade them as their own brilliant ideas. Ever heard your legislator say, "I authored a Protect Your Freedom Bill!"? Odds are, they didn't write a word of it and might not even know what it says.
Think about it. Someone hands you a completed assignment and says, "Sign your name." Now imagine they guarantee you'll get an A, the kind of A that makes you a rockstar on a legislator scorecard. Suddenly, you're the star student, the golden representative. Why would any legislator want to pass that kind of recognition up?
Side note: Did you know the median annual salary for lobbyists in SC is approximately $95K, with the top earning over $100K? Think tank employees can make as much or even more than lobbyists.
Also worth noting: How many of these types of organizations exist in our state? A LOT. Spend some time at the legislative statehouse in Columbia, and you'll see who hangs around there most of the time. Hint: it's not the average South Carolinian.
Now that we know how lobbyists work, let's talk about their tweed-wearing cousins — think tanks. On paper, they champion clarity and cogency as nonpartisan policy researchers. Conservative ones claim to stand for limited government and prosperity. But back on earth, they shun simplicity and sell policy, conclusions bought and paid for by those on their donor list. The scholarly act is a front. Funding dictates findings, every time.
The easiest way to spot the difference between these influence peddlers?
Lobbyists at least have the decency to look you in the eye when selling something. Think tanks do the exact same selling, only hidden behind impressive credentials and footnotes, all designed to fool you into believing they accidentally discovered their conclusions through some noble, impartial academic pursuit.
At their core, both groups are professional opinion shapers who excel at making you believe their agenda is your idea. They are masters of persuasion; they package their clients' wish lists as public necessities, turning paid-for policies into laws while making you think you wanted them all along.
Here's what this looks like in action:
A think tank releases a report touting S62, the government school choice bill, as the key to "empowering parents" and "rescuing children" from failing public schools. The message is catchy, relatable, emotional, and impossible not to rally behind.
Who doesn't want to save children?
Media channels flood with targeted ads and social media videos featuring struggling families whose lives will supposedly transform overnight. Slick training sessions arm local "advocates" with perfectly crafted talking points. Cue the emotional manipulation masterpieces with videos loaded with sad music swelling at the right moment, grateful parents with tears in their eyes, and a carefully curated rainbow of faces to make the message seem universally embraced. Every phrase, such as "educational freedom," "the money follows the child," and "give parents a choice," has been focus-grouped and polished to perfection, making it nearly impossible to question without being labeled anti-family or anti-child.
Behind the scenes, think tank recruits transform ordinary citizens into unwitting salespeople. What looks like an organic grassroots movement is a well-orchestrated campaign choreographed by the think tank's playbook and bankrolled by national groups poised to profit handsomely from this bill.
And surprise, it worked! The bill passed, celebrated as a triumph for "families and educational freedom." Lawmakers point to the "overwhelming grassroots support" as evidence they're listening to voters.
But did South Carolinians demand more government control in education? Did anyone ask to pay higher taxes for yet another government program? Doubt it. Most people don't wake up craving more government handouts until they're convinced they can't live without them.
So whose voices counted? Certainly not yours.
The BIG Problem
Think tanks and lobbyists are pros at stealing your voice. That's how we end up with laws that look like wins on Facebook posts but make bad government services even worse. That's also how we get a steady increase in regulations, restrictions, and control over our lives, while ensuring we're all walking a straight line under the almighty government's control.
Why are we letting this happen?
The answer isn't complicated. We're being played by experts who've mastered the science of persuasion. The same tactics that get you to choose one brand over another are now choosing your laws for you.
Marketing strategies transform reality. They shape what we think, change how we behave, entertain us when we're bored, distract us when we're paying attention to the wrong things, and slowly rewire our brains until we can't tell the difference between what's true.
A well-crafted persuasion tactic is ruthless. It builds a cult of conviction that silences dissent by turning opposition into the enemy. That's how powerful it is. That's how South Carolinians end up supporting laws do nothing but grow government control.
The Consequences
If these groups actually worked for South Carolinians, we'd see more freedom, not more government.
Every legislative session, we hear the same song and dance. Legislators boast about passing bills that fix this or address that. Yet nothing changes. Well, that's not entirely true. One thing keeps changing: government spending. Meanwhile, we're stuck with the same government-controlled, stale services that solve nothing. Not for the person struggling to find and afford quality healthcare. Not for the small business owner drowning in insurance costs. Not for the driver swerving to avoid potholes every morning.
The ones holding the reins profit while the rest of us pay for scraps.
The bills that get passed protect industries, reward donors, and arm our elected legislators with catchy campaign slogans that help them get reelected.
It's a rigged cycle. Legislators vote for bills written by policy influencers, then campaign on those "accomplishments." We voters, conditioned by the same marketing machines, reward them with our votes, essentially rehiring the same puppets whose strings are being pulled by the factions we're frustrated with. We think we're voting for change, but we're actually reinforcing the very system that silences us.
Reclaiming Our Voice
If the legislative process is ever to work for us, for crying out loud, we must abandon the role of passive spectators and step into the arena as active participants. We MUST invest the time and effort to pay closer attention to what’s happening behind closed doors. Without that commitment to getting informed, staying informed, and vigilantly monitoring the actions of those in power, we will keep risking our voices being drowned out by those more than willing to speak for us and shape the narrative to their advantage.
Once you open your eyes to how the game is played, the carefully constructed facade starts to crack, revealing the raw, unsettling truth of what's really happening behind the glossy political wins, the rehearsed campaign promises, and the relentless marketing machine designed to keep us complacent.
Questions We Should Be Asking:
Who's benefiting from the bills our legislators are so proud of passing?
How many of our legislators could explain the details of the bills they vote for?
If lobbying groups represent special interests, who's representing yours?
What would our laws look like if they were written by South Carolinians for South Carolinians?
How many bills passed last session originated from citizen concerns versus lobbyist priorities?
When did we decide that expertise means whatever wealthy donors want?
What would happen if legislators had to disclose who wrote each bill they introduce?
How did we end up in a system where your voice matters less than someone who's paid to speak?
Lobbying groups and think tanks are masters of manipulation, paid to secure exactly what they want. They have the resources to push their agenda however they please. With talking points locked and loaded, they get their voices heard and they always get what they’re after.
But what about us?
The longer we sit quietly, accept this as the norm, and support these faction types, the more they assume we're fine with how things are. Their voices drown out everything else. If we don’t speak up, and soon, we risk being silenced for good.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not constitute legal or professional advice. ConservaTruth assumes no liability for any actions taken based on this content. Read more.
Subscribe to ConservaTruth's Email Newsletter for curated insights on South Carolina's legislative activities and conservative viewpoints, delivered straight to your inbox! With vetted and easy-to-understand information, our newsletter empowers you to become an informed and engaged citizen, actively participating in safeguarding our cherished Constitutional values. Don’t miss out on crucial updates—join our community of informed conservatives today.
Comments